Top 5 Desserts You Must Try at Soft N’ Yummy
When it comes to dessert, not all sweet spots are created equal. In the heart of Cranford, New Jersey, a gem has emerged that’s redefining what it means to satisfy a craving: Soft N’ Yummy. While this dessert shop offers a menu full of creative, comforting, and eye-catching items, five stand out as absolute must-tries. Whether you’re a local or visiting the area, these five treats are the cornerstone of the Soft N’ Yummy experience.
1. Signature Soft-Serve Swirl
There’s something timeless about soft-serve. But at Soft N’ Yummy, it’s more than just a cone—it’s a canvas. Their signature swirl is velvety, cool, and rich, made from high-quality dairy ingredients that melt perfectly on the tongue. Customers can choose from classic vanilla, decadent chocolate, or a perfectly balanced swirl of both.
What truly elevates this treat are the toppings. You’re encouraged to go wild with crushed Oreos, rainbow sprinkles, gummy bears, caramel drizzle, and even fresh fruit. It’s a simple treat turned extraordinary, and the best part is, you can make it yours every time.
Pro Tip: Ask for your swirl in a dipped waffle cone for a crunchy, chocolatey upgrade.
2. Over-the-Top Sundaes
If you’re the kind of dessert lover who believes more is more, the sundaes at Soft N’ Yummy will speak to your soul. Built in layers, these creations aren’t just delicious—they’re Instagram gold. Think hot fudge, gooey brownies, scoops of ice cream, whipped cream towers, cookie crumbles, and cherries on top. Every spoonful is a surprise of textures and flavors.
Their signature sundaes rotate seasonally, with limited-time creations featuring ingredients like peppermint bark in winter or strawberry shortcake in spring. But classics like the Brownie Bliss and Banana Bonanza are always available to deliver that ultimate indulgence.
Why We Love It: It’s not just dessert—it’s dessert theater in a bowl.
3. Handcrafted Milkshakes
Milkshakes are having a renaissance, and Soft N’ Yummy is leading the charge in Cranford. Their shakes are thick, creamy, and built to impress. Each one starts with premium ice cream blended to the perfect consistency, and then it gets fun: whipped cream, sauces, cookies, marshmallows, and even whole donuts have been spotted topping these frosty delights.
Choose from fan-favorite flavors like Cookies & Cream, Salted Caramel, and Birthday Cake, or create your own. The milkshakes are served in tall cups with wide straws and plenty of personality.
Customer Favorite: The S’mores Shake—complete with toasted marshmallow fluff, crushed graham crackers, and drizzled chocolate—is a must-have.
4. Seasonal Specials You Can’t Miss
One of the things that keeps people coming back to Soft N’ Yummy is their rotating seasonal menu. It’s where their creativity truly shines. You never know what’s going to hit the menu next—Pumpkin Pie sundaes in the fall, Peppermint Mocha milkshakes in the winter, Watermelon Sorbet in the summer. Every season brings new inspiration and flavor combinations that align with the mood of the moment.
This focus on seasonality keeps the menu exciting and gives customers something to look forward to year-round. The staff is also great at taking customer feedback into account, so if something becomes a fan favorite, it might just return as a regular menu item.
Don’t Miss: Their Apple Crumble Sundae in autumn—it tastes just like grandma’s pie.
5. Premium Hard Ice Cream
While soft-serve gets a lot of love, their hard ice cream deserves its own spotlight. Soft N’ Yummy sources premium ingredients to craft rich, creamy scoops that rival the best ice cream parlors in the country. Classic flavors like Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and Mint Chocolate Chip are joined by more adventurous offerings like Mango Cheesecake, Dulce de Leche, and Cotton Candy Explosion.
The texture is ultra-smooth, the flavors are bold, and the portions are generous. Whether you grab a single scoop or stack three in a cone, it’s a nostalgic experience with a modern twist.
Customization Options: Add a drizzle of fudge or caramel, toss on some toppings, or turn your scoop into an ice cream sandwich with fresh-baked cookies.
The Soft N’ Yummy Experience
What sets Soft N’ Yummy apart isn’t just the quality of the ingredients or the variety of flavors—it’s the atmosphere. The shop has a playful, inviting energy that makes dessert feel like an experience, not just an afterthought. From the cheerful decor to the upbeat staff and carefully curated menu, every part of the brand is designed to make you smile.
Families come in for post-dinner treats, friends gather to share milkshakes and stories, and couples swing by on date night for a cone and a walk. It’s a place that feels local but delivers a world-class dessert experience.
The Art of Dessert Innovation
In an industry filled with copycats and standard offerings, Soft N’ Yummy thrives on innovation. Whether it’s introducing color-changing cones, dairy-free soft serve options, or collaboration specials with other local businesses, the brand always finds new ways to stay fresh and relevant.
Their dessert artisans often experiment with flavors and textures that aren’t easy to find elsewhere. Cereal milk soft-serve? Cotton candy sundaes? Edible glitter on your scoop? All on the table.
Sustainability Note: Soft N’ Yummy is also exploring more eco-friendly packaging and local sourcing initiatives—another reason to feel good about indulging.
What Customers Are Saying
One glance at their online reviews, and a few things become clear:
- People rave about the flavor and consistency of the soft-serve.
- The shop is praised for its cleanliness and cheerful staff.
- The sundaes are often described as “over the top—in the best way.”
- Repeat customers love the seasonal menu surprises.
It’s not just a hit with kids—adults who grew up on soft-serve cones are rediscovering the joy of ice cream thanks to Soft N’ Yummy’s thoughtful flavors and textures.
Conclusion: Your Next Dessert Adventure Starts Here
Soft N’ Yummy is more than just a local dessert shop—it’s a destination for sweet moments, bold flavors, and unforgettable treats. Whether you’re on a mission to find the best milkshake in New Jersey or just want a quick scoop on a summer evening, this Cranford hotspot delivers every time.
The top five desserts we’ve covered are just the beginning. With a constantly evolving menu and a commitment to quality and creativity, there’s always something new to discover. So grab your spoon or your cone and get ready for a sugar rush done right.